Twitter

Entries in sms (4)

Sunday
Mar082009

LATAM 2009: A Mosaic of Opportunities

"When we long for life without difficulties, remind us that oaks grow strong in contrary winds and diamonds are made under pressure." ~Peter Marshall


Technology companies tend to view the Latin American mobile market as a single block; this might be in part because of the similarities in key demographic and economic factors including language, GDP and mobile penetration as well as the presence of two large players -Telefonica and America Movil- that dominate the region.

The Latin American mobile market, however, is incredibly complex. Each country shows remarkably different subscriber usage behavior patterns and adoption of technologies; this translates into different needs and consequently, different opportunities for each market.

Opportunity Maps are particularly useful in analyzing and understanding these differences. The chart above shows three key factors: (x) Average Monthly SMS; (y) MOU - Minutes of Usage; and ARPU - Monthly Average Revenue per User (bubble size) for the six largest markets in the region; Brazil, Mexico, Chile, Colombia, Venezuela and Argentina.(1)

Some opportunities can come from increased MOU or SMS in countries that show low usage, introducing SMS based services in countries with low voice usage or new data services where usage and ARPU show potential for rapid adoption.

Some key differences stand out in the chart above:

  • Mexico, Venezuela and Chile have a larger ARPU; Colombia and Brazil are on the lower end.
  • Venezuela and Argentina show SMS usage above 100 messages per month; Brazil and Chile are almost in the single digits.
  • Voice usage is significantly higher in Colombia and Chile and lower in Venezuela and Brazil.

The adoption of text messaging can be explained by a number of factors. In Colombia, the price war between operators a few years ago resulted in the launch of the "Pioneros" program by Ola (now Millicom/Tigo) with heavy discounts for voice. In countries such as Chile and Colombia, subscribers pay about the same for a text message and a phone call; this might explain why texting has not taken off.

Regulation also plays an important role; in countries like Venezuela and Brazil, the introduction of a regulation prompt for transfer to voice mail on busy/no answer advising callers that they will be charged for the call has resulted in increased slamdown and redial attempts. This impacts network productivity with a large number of calls generating traffic but no revenue.

From the map above, we can identify opportunities for call completion solutions that influence subscriber usage in countries with low MOU such as Venezuela and Brazil. This includes replacing voice mail with "A" party solutions such as availability notification for the calling party.

In countries such as Venezuela and Argentina, where SMS usage is high, there are opportunities for other forms of messaging such as Mobile Instant Messaging (GSMA PIM); subscribers are clearly using texting as a form of instant messaging.

This year operators have made it clear that they will have to limit CAPEX to a minimum to maintain healthy cash flows. Since the region is still expected to grow in number of subscribers, expanding capacity of existing network infrastructure will be their top priority. However, as the chart above clearly shows, there are other opportunities that operators can explore to increase revenue, despite the fact that subscribers are expected to curtail spending.

Some opportunities can be found in improving service and network productivity; i.e. increasing output using the same infrastructure or expanding capacity with minimal CAPEX. An added benefit is that some of these opportunities can be positioned as new services; this year operators will have limited resources but they cannot afford to miss opportunities to maitain or improve their position in the market.

For technology vendors, dealing with Latin America is becoming increasingly challenging; not only is the region incredibly complex, but the big players in the region -America Movil, Telefonica Movistar and Millicom- have consolidated their presence and gained negotiating power in the last few years.

Understanding the market and the specific needs and opportunities in each country, however, can help identify leads in Latin America, a market that is complex, fascinating and full of hidden opportunities.

(1) Source Pyramid Research, 2009

Tuesday
Feb102009

Will 2009 be the year for Mobile Instant Messaging in Latin America?

Subscriber usage behavior clearly shows that the Latin American market is ready for a solution such as GSMA Personal IM, also known as SMS 2.0 (Telefonica Spain, Acision) or Instant SMS (Comverse).
The chart above measures three elements: Data ARPU (x), mobile penetration (y) and average number of SMS messages per user per month for several Latin American countries(1).
The countries with SMS usage in the region are Venezuela, Argentina and Ecuador; with Colombia having the lowest SMS usage. These countries also have a higher data ARPU; this is not surprising as in Latin America 70% to 90% of data revenue comes from SMS.
What's relevant here is subscriber SMS usage, surpassing 100 messages per user per month as in the case of Venezuela and more recently Argentina; this tells us that heavy users are actually having live conversations using SMS; in other words, a segment of subscribers uses SMS as Instant Messaging, with a higher number of messages going back and forth per conversation than the average 2.5 we normally see in SMS conversations.
Personal IM is a sophisticated network based service that requires interaction with a handset application and deployment of client based solutions can be somewhat complicated, especially when operators have a large number of handsets in the market. Its success will also depend on providing the service to the mass market and not to a small niche of postpaid subscribers with high end handsets. However, in Latin America subscribers tend to spend more on handsets than on services, this means that a large subscriber base have the right type of handset that supports client based services such as Personal IM.
In addition, a large segment of subscribers is already using SMS as an Instant Messaging tool. This means that mobile operators are not offering a solution to meet subscribers' needs, and are leaving money on the table.
With voice revenue flattening and even declining in most of the region, and with mobile penetration fast reaching saturation in the more advanced markets, operators need to find new sources of revenue. Increasing data revenue is one of the options operators have to address this issue and Personal IM is a service with a high probability of success.
Mobile IM has been very successful in the USA and Australia (Portal IM) and somewhat successful in Europe and Asia (Personal IM). In Latin America, however, we still have to see operators pay serious attention to this service. Telefonica Movistar launched an initiative for SMS 2.0 and Brazilian operators are working on a joint effort to launch GSMA Personal IM but we have not seen any live deployments yet (see update below).
I am being facetious with the title of this post since a little more than a year ago I published a post titled Will 2008 be the year for Mobile Instant Messaging in Latin America? It obviously was not, but maybe it will happen in 2009!
UPDATE FEBRUARY 11th, 2009 1:44 pm EST
GSMA's Personal IM project latest e-newsletter contains some interesting updates that are very relevant to my post. In addition to four new launches in Asia and Europe, I want to highlight their announcement that they expect "significant developments in Latin America in the coming months – including the launch of interoperable PIM services in Brazil". Brazilian operators have been working on this project for several years and it's great to see their efforts come to fruition.
There are two very important elements in the Brazilian project: first of all, the participation of all major GSM operators; secondly, they are following the GSMA Personal IM initiative, with interconnection between operators and SMS.
Some interesting data from their newsletter:

Fast Facts

  • 70 countries involved
  • 106 operators involved
  • 40 operators with live IM services
  • 2.4 billion (2) subscribers covered globally by operators committed to the initiative
(1) Statistics based on data projection from Pyramid Research for 2008. Actual usage shows the numbers for mobile penetration in Argentina are higher, reaching 100% and SMS average usage is also expected to be higher for 2008. Actual usage not available at the time this post was prepared.
(2) GSMA Wireless Intelligence, January 2009